How to Nail It Every Time: Your Guide for Choosing the Right Roofing Contractor

Look, we get it. Roof replacement or repair isn’t exactly at the top of your wish list. It’s a major investment, and unfortunately, roofing contractors don’t always have the best reputation—because, well, there are some bad apples out there.

Good news: We’re not one of them.

Since day one, CoMitted 365 Roofing & Exteriors has been on a mission to change how homeowners in St. Cloud, Minnesota, and beyond view roofing contractors. It doesn’t have to be all smoke and mirrors. We believe the key to better results is better communication, and we are dedicated to operating out of a place of true transparency.

And we don’t just talk the talk—we have the proof to back it up. CoMitted 365 was recently named a BBB Torch Awards for Ethics and Quality finalist. If that’s not a major Green Flag, we don’t know what is.

If you’re searching for a trusted roofing contractor and want to avoid costly mistakes, we’ve got you covered. Here’s what you need to know before hiring a pro.


Step 1: Get Multiple Bids

Your best friend’s sister’s friend who knows a guy who hired a guy is NOT the answer to all your roofing problems. While word of mouth is valuable (and we’re grateful for referrals!), it shouldn’t be your only deciding factor when choosing a roofing contractor.

When starting your search, we highly recommend getting multiple roofing estimates. This process helps you compare:

✅ Pricing – Understand what’s included in each bid.

✅ Materials – Not all shingles are created equal.

✅ Warranties – A strong warranty can save you money long-term.

✅ Contractor Personality – You want someone you get along with and can trust.

Be sure to ask plenty of questions and read the fine print. If a quote seems too good to be true, it probably is. A low bid could mean cut corners and poor workmanship, which can lead to leaks, water damage, and costly repairs.

Your home is a deeply special and personal place, so when you decide to repair or replace your roof, you want to work with someone you trust—a company that allows you to sleep easy at night knowing they will do the best job possible. Gathering multiple bids ensures you make an informed decision and hire a trusted roofing contractor who delivers quality work.


Red Flags to Watch Out For

Choosing the right roofing contractor isn’t just about price, materials, and warranties. Unfortunately, roofing scams and poor workmanship have given the industry a bad reputation—but that’s not us!

We urge you to ask the BIG questions upfront and keep an eye out for these major red flags:

🚩 No License or Insurance – Always verify credentials. If a contractor can’t provide proof, run for the hills!

🚩 High-Pressure Sales Tactics – A trusted roofing contractor will give you time to decide. If someone is pushing you to sign on the spot, that’s a problem.

🚩 Large Upfront Payments – Standard deposits should be reasonable. If a contractor asks for an unusually high amount upfront, they may not be financially stable—or worse, they could disappear.

🚩 Lack of a Written Contract – If it’s not in writing, you have no protection if something goes wrong. A solid contract outlines pricing, scope of work, and warranties—no exceptions.

🚩 No BBB Accreditation or Bad Reviews – Do your homework. Read Google reviews, check BBB ratings, and ask for referrals. If a contractor has negative reviews, unresolved complaints, or no online presence, take that as a sign to walk away.

As industry experts, we’ve seen it all—no contracts, no insurance, shady deals. These issues damage the industry’s credibility, but there are still contractors who prioritize integrity and quality.

With nearly 200 five-star Google reviews and recognition from the Better Business Bureau, we’re proud to say CoMitted 365 has zero red flags—only green lights ahead.


Green Flags of a Reliable Contractor

While there are plenty of red flags to avoid, let’s talk about what makes a great roofing contractor. These green flags indicate you’re working with a professional who prioritizes quality, honesty, and customer satisfaction.

Licensed, Insured, and Local Expertise – A reputable roofing company will have the proper licenses and insurance to protect you and their workers. Plus, choosing a local contractor means they understand your area’s weather challenges and building codes.

Transparent Pricing & Detailed Estimates – No guesswork, no surprises. A trustworthy contractor will provide a clear, itemized estimate outlining the cost of materials, labor, and warranties so you know exactly what you’re paying for.

Proven Track Record & Strong Reviews – Customer feedback speaks volumes. Look for a roofing company with five-star reviews, positive testimonials, and a history of delivering quality work. Bonus points if they’re BBB accredited!

Recognized for Ethics and Quality – Awards and industry recognition matter. You want a contractor who is recognized for their advancements in the industry and demonstrates integrity, transparency, and a commitment to doing business the right way.

Solid Warranties & Commitment to Quality – A great contractor stands behind their work. Look for companies that offer strong warranties on both materials and labor, ensuring your roof is protected for years to come.

At CoMitted 365 Roofing & Exteriors, we check all these boxes—and then some. Our team is fully licensed, insured, and backed by nearly 200 five-star Google reviews. When you hire us, you can trust you’re getting expert craftsmanship, transparent pricing, and exceptional service—every time.


The BBB Seal: Why It Matters

When hiring a roofing contractor, you want to know you’re working with someone you can trust. That’s where the Better Business Bureau (BBB) seal comes in. When you see this logo, you can rest easy knowing it’s a mark of credibility, integrity, and customer trust.

BBB Accredited Business

Why Choose a BBB-Accredited Contractor?

🔹 Commitment to Ethical Business Practices – BBB-accredited businesses must meet strict standards for honesty, transparency, and customer service.

🔹 Accountability & Conflict Resolution – If issues arise, the BBB provides a neutral platform for dispute resolution, ensuring contractors are held accountable.

🔹 Verified Reputation – The BBB evaluates customer reviews, complaint history, and business practices, giving homeowners an honest look at a contractor’s track record.

🔹 Recognized for Excellence – Some companies go above and beyond, earning recognition for their high standards in ethics and quality. For example, CoMitted 365 is a proud finalist for the BBB Torch Award, which honors businesses that demonstrate exceptional integrity and customer commitment.

When you see the BBB seal, you can feel confident that you’re hiring a trustworthy roofing contractor who will stand behind their work. At CoMitted 365, we believe in honesty, quality, and treating customers like family, and our BBB recognition is just one way we prove it.


When choosing a roofing contractor, you want to find someone who puts quality and ethics before profit. Don’t be swayed by low bids, high-pressure sales tactics, or other red flags. Take the time to find a contractor who prioritizes your needs, communicates openly, and delivers exceptional results.

At CoMitted 365 Roofing & Exteriors, we take pride in serving St. Cloud, Minnesota, with professionalism, transparency, and efficiency. From the first call to the final touches, we make sure your roofing project is completed to the highest standards—on time and with care.

If you’re looking for a trusted roofing contractor who stays true to their word, we’re the team for you. Contact us today for a roofing experience built on integrity, expertise, and customer satisfaction.

 

Contact us today!

For a roofing experience built on integrity, expertise, and customer satisfaction.

How Can We Help?

How Can We Help?

"*" indicates required fields

Select Services*
Your Name*